9 Guardians Who Won't Return in 2024

Cleveland needs to re-tool after a disappointing 2023 campaign, which means these guys have to go.
Nine Cleveland Guardians players who won't be back with the team in 2024.
Nine Cleveland Guardians players who won't be back with the team in 2024. / David Richard-USA TODAY Sports
9 of 9

9. James Karinchak

Karinchak did not have a good year in 2023, and his regression definitely played a significant role in Cleveland's struggles. His ERA nearly doubled from 2.08 to 4.15 as many of his peripherals regressed. Despite pitching the same number of innings (39) as 2022, he finished with more hits, walks and home runs as well as fewer strikeouts, resulting in an unsightly 4.97 FIP and 1.36 WHIP (both career-worsts).

The Guardians can't afford a repeat of that performance in 2024, so this winter is a good team to move on from the 28-year-old. Whether they include him in a trade package or DFA him, Karinchak needs to go.

The five-year veteran has now finished with an ERA over four in two of the last three seasons, so his struggles weren't just isolated to 2023. He's also entering his first year of arbitration, which means he's likely due for a raise.

Cleveland should send him elsewhere before he gets too expensive and the front office is stuck overpaying for a middling reliever.

These players may be on the outs, but you should get in on the action at Bet365. They're offering new users $150 in bonus bets for simply claiming the offer below and placing a first wager of just $5. This deal even works with a bet on any game, so you can wager on anything you want. This promotion won't last forever, though, so act now!

In other Guardians news: