Grim Week 1 Browns-Bengals Predictions Given By Betting Insiders (But Are They Right?)

Should Browns fans be worried about the predictions floating around for our Week 1 matchup against the Bengals?

Browns vs Bengals Week 1 betting predictions paint a grim picture for Cleveland fans.
Browns vs Bengals Week 1 betting predictions paint a grim picture for Cleveland fans. / Kareem Elgazzar-USA TODAY Sports

At this point Cleveland Browns fans are way too cynical to ever be truly optimistic, but with the 2023 season approaching, fans are as close to optimistic as they can get. Unfortunately, any good that comes this season might take a while to arrive.

The Browns meet the AFC North favorites in Week 1, and betting insiders are projecting this one to be a rough start to the season for the Browns.

Browns vs Bengals Week 1 Betting Predictions

Low-Scoring Game for the Wrong Reasons

BetSided's Iain MacMillan has given his betting picks for every game in Week 1, and his pick for the Browns-Bengals matchup isn't all that bad. He simply likes taking Under 47.5 points — saying nothing of who is the better value to win this game. That doesn't mean he's not painting a worrying picture for the Browns though:

"When it comes to the Browns, I have no faith in Deshaun Watson looking like the version of himself that was an MVP candidate with the Texans. He completed just 58.2% of passes in six games last season.

I expect the Bengals to ease Burrow into the season and the Browns to largely stick to the run game."

Iaian MacMillan, BetSided

A low-scoring game isn't necessarily a bad thing, especially because this Browns team's strength is clearly on the defensive side of the ball. But the reasoning for a low score on either side (Watson just not being good enough to score big points compared to Burrow simply not being unleashed enough to score big points) is a little worrying.

It's also not going to be ideal if the Browns need to lean on Nick Chubb heavily right from Week 1. Chubb is obviously going to be a huge piece of this offense, but it's a long season and anything we can do to keep him fresh down the stretch is going to be important. Giving him a massive workload in the season opener would not be a good long-term sign.

The Only Ones Upset are Browns Fans

Betting insider Peter Dewey also headed over to StripeHype to give his prediction for the season's first Browns vs. Bengals matchup, and this one's even worse for Browns fans. He doesn't see an upset in the cards in Week 1.

"The Browns should be improved this season with a full season of Watson, but the fact that Newsome and Ward are nursing injuries is a major concern against this Cincinnati receiving corps.

As long as Burrow is healthy enough to play, I think the Bengals can run away with this game"

Peter Dewey, Stripe Hype

Once again, the whole overarching tone here is that this game is about the Bengals and Joe Burrow — that unless something goes wrong it's going to be the Bengals doing whatever they want.

And with Denzel Ward's injury plus the huge question mark around what version of Deshaun Watson we'll see in 2023, it's not hard to see why this is the prevailing view on the matchup.

So the two insider picks combine to give us a low-scoring Bengals win — not exactly a fun season opener to watch for fans in Cleveland. But these are national betting insiders. Does having a more intimate knowledge of the Browns let us paint a different picture?

Factory of Sadness' Take

First off, I can't disagree with either MacMillan or Dewey when it comes to the Deshaun Watson situation. I do think he turns things around this season, and that having more time to focus and build chemistry in this offense is going to make a big difference.

But until we see some evidence of that (he wasn't exactly lights-out in training camp), that's not something to put your money behind.

I do think this is a much tougher out for Burrow and the Bengals offense than people realize, though. The Browns legitimately might have the best defense in the NFL.

The Bengals struggle in pass protection, Burrow is playing hurt, and the Browns have Myles Garrett and Za'Darius Smith on the edges, with Dalvin Tomlinson and Shelby Harris rushing up the middle. Burrow is going to get hit a ton. He simply won't have enough time and space in the pocket to really take advantage of the Ward injury. It's going to have to be all short passes and an increased emphasis on the run game from Cincy.

The Watson question mark is enough that I'm not going to go out and pick a straight-up upset here, but I do like the Browns to cover the spread, and agree that the Under is probably the right pick on the total.

No matter how you want to bet the Browns-Bengals game, all the amazing new-user offers around the industry let you cash in even with a losing bet in Week 1. FanDuel, Bet365, Caesars Sportsbook, BetMGM and DraftKings are all offering guaranteed "bet and get" bonuses. That means you sign up through our exclusive Factory of Sadness links, place your first bet, and whether it wins or loses you get your full bonus either way. These bonuses range from $200 to $250, and FanDuel's even includes an extra $100 discount on NFL Sunday ticket. You're eligible to claim as many offers as you like, so cash in as much as you can in Week 1 before they expire!

It can be hard deciding between all the sportsbooks, so we've put together comprehensive reviews of a few of the top options that can be found by clicking on any of the following sportsbook names: FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, Bet365

Odds refresh periodically and are subject to change.

21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER