Embarrassing Story Proves Cutting Cade York Was the Browns' Only Choice

If you had any doubts about whether cutting Cade York was the right move, then you'll want to hear this story.

The Browns had no choice but to cut Cade York after this embarrassing situation in practice.
The Browns had no choice but to cut Cade York after this embarrassing situation in practice. / Jeff Lange / USA TODAY NETWORK

Kicking in the NFL is mostly mental. These guys are all totally physically capable of making most of the kicks they're asked to attempt in games, but the challenges and pressures of live-game situations complicate that.

Well, Cade York was clearly mentally broken in Browns training camp. This brutal story highlights exactly how bad things got.

Cade York Struggles

York was bad as a rookie in 2022, making just 75.0% of his field goal attempts (No. 31 in the NFL). He was even worse in the 2023 preseason, going just 50%. But his play in practice continued to earn him chances with Cleveland. The coaching staff knew he was capable of making the kicks because they had seen it firsthand. He just needed to convert that practice success into game success.

Instead, he went the other way. York reportedly spent about 30 minutes kicking field goals without making a single one, and the practice performance was described as "a total disaster."

Honestly, I feel kind of bad for York. Going from a fourth-round pick to cut in a little over a year is a total rollercoaster, and it's clear that his struggles have now fully gotten into his head.

Regressing on the practice field rather than progressing toward turning his practice success into game success had to be the final straw, though. The Browns can't roster a kicker just because they feel bad for him, especially when they have legitimate playoff hopes this year.

And look, there may well be room for York on the practice squad. Maybe getting to reset and hone his craft without the pressure of kicking on Sundays is what he needs.

But things may be too far gone for him in Cleveland after a performance like this one. What he might need to really jump-start a career revival is a change of scenery. If anyone else does decide to roll the dice on York, I'm sure there won't be too many Browns fans upset about it.

If you want to jump-start your betting bankroll, you can do it with a guaranteed $200 bonus on Bet365, which pays out as long as you place a $1 wager. You get paid the full $200 bonus whether that bet wins or loses -- just make sure you sign up through the exclusive Factory of Sadness link below and deposit at least $10 to unlock the bonus.